Mera Peak Vs Island Peak climbing is two of the most popular trekking peaks located close to each other in the Khumbu region of Nepal. A mountain range between the Hongu and Khumbu Valleys separates them. Mera Peak is higher than Island Peak and easier to climb. Island Peak is more challenging with steeper ice climbs. Both peaks suit beginners, but Mera Peak can be climbed without special mountaineering skills, while Island Peak requires some basic knowledge.
Mera Peak is high but has fewer challenges, while Island Peak has more difficult sections that need proper climbing knowledge. The headwall, ridge to the summit, and icefalls on Island Peak make it harder. Both peaks require trekkers to be fit and have little to no prior climbing experience.
From the top of these peaks, you get stunning mountain views. The highlight of these treks is the Amphu Lapcha Pass, which is 5,780 meters high. However, there are some important differences between these two peaks.
Table of Contents
Mera Peak
Mera Peak is the tallest trekking peak in the Nepali Himalayas and is excellent for beginners wanting to learn snow skills. It’s famous for its stunning views of five of the world’s highest mountains: Lhotse (8,516 meters), Cho Oyu (8,188 meters), Makalu (8,485 meters), Kanchenjunga (8,586 meters), and Mt. Everest (8,848 meters). Mera Peak has three summits: Mera Peak North (6,476 meters), Mera Peak South (6,065 meters), and Mera Peak Central (6,461 meters).
Most expeditions go to the Mera Peak Central. Sen Tenzing and Jimmy Roberts first climbed the peak on May 20, 1953. Roberts, who helped start the trekking industry in Nepal in the early 1960s, was honored with the Sagarmatha National Award in 2005. Since the first ascent, Mera Peak has become a popular training climb for higher mountains.
Read More For Mera peak Expedition
Island Peak
Island Peak, also known as Imja Tse, is a popular trekking peak in Nepal. It was first climbed in 1953 by a British team, Tenzing Norgay, Charles Evans, Charles Wylie, and Alf Gregory. The British team claimed Island Peak as part of their training to climb Everest. Since then, many climbers have used it as a practice climb before attempting Everest.
Island Peak, standing at 6,189 meters, extends from the southern ridge of Lhotse Shar. When viewed from Dingboche, it looks like an island in a sea of ice, which is how it got its name from English mountaineer Eric Shipton in 1953. The slopes of Island Peak are a bit challenging but not too hard, making it a great peak for beginners to test their mountaineering skills before climbing higher peaks.
Read More For Everest Base Camp And Island Peak
Mera Peak Vs Island Peak climbing
| Category | Mera Peak | Island Peak |
| Elevation | Higher at 6,476 meters | Lower at 6,189 meters |
| Technical Difficulty | Easier than Island Peak, suitable for beginners | More technical, requires mountaineering skills |
| Challenges | Few crevasses, high altitude | Steep ice climbs, headwall, icefalls |
| Climbing Season | Similar (Spring and Autumn) | Similar (Spring and Autumn) |
| Time Required | Longer expedition, 18-22 days | Shorter expedition, 14-20 days |
| Cost | Generally higher, $2,500 – $3,000 | Generally lower, $2,000 – $2,500 |
| Popularity | Less crowded, more remote | More popular, busier |
Difficulty Level of Mera and Island Peak
Mera Peak
Mera Peak is a non-technical trekking peak with moderate difficulty. In the Alpine Grading System, it is rated as PD (Peu Difficile), meaning there are some challenging sections, but they are not very technical.
Previously, Mea Peak was rated as an Alpine Grade F (Facile), indicating it was straightforward and had no technical parts along the route. However, the difficulty level was upgraded to PD due to changes in the glacier and some technical parts along the route. Climbers must overcome a snow dome 40-50 meters before the summit, rising jumars, and fixed ropes.
Island Peak
Island Peak climbing is similar in difficulty to Mera Peak and is rated as a moderate expedition in the Himalayan grading system. In the e Alpine Grading System, it has a 2B difficulty level. This means some technical sections on the route require mountaineering tools. Common gear for the Island Peal includes harnesses, helmets, ascenders, descenders, ice axes, crampons, and ropes.
The vertical wall near the summit is one of the most challenging parts. Climbers must use a harness and fixed ropes to move between anchor points. However, the expedition is not as rough or strenuous as climbing an 8,000-meter mountain.
Views and Scenery
Mera Peak
- Panoramic Vistas: From the summit of Mera Peak, climbers are rewarded with breathtaking panoramic views of five of the world’s highest peaks: Everest, Lhotse, Makalu, Cho Oyu, and Kanchenjunga. This rare sight is a highlight for many trekkers and climbers.
- Surrounding Landscape: The Mera Peak offers a sweeping view of the Hinku and Hongu valleys, filled with glaciers and rugged terrain. The snow-capped peaks and ice formations create a stunning and serene atmosphere.
- Experience: The Mera Peak ascent is less technical than Island Peak, making it accessible for climbers with basic mountaineering skills. The views are vast and give a sense of the immense scale of the Himalayas.
Island Peak
- Dramatic Scenery: From the summit of Island Peak, climbers can see the towering south face of Lhotse, which stands out prominently. The peak offers close-up views of the surrounding peaks, including Nuptse, Baruntse, and Ama Dablam.
- Close-Up Peaks: The views from Island Peak are more intimate, with towering peaks almost within arm’s reach. The scenery includes sharp, jagged ridges and dramatic ice walls.
- Experience: The Island Peak’s climb is more technical, involving glacier crossing and a steep headwall ascent. The sense of achievement from reaching the summit is complemented by the stunning, rugged views that feel closer and more immediate.
Weather and Climbing Seasons
The weather at Mera Peak or Island Peak can be hard to predict. The climate in the Himalayas changes quickly. The weather at high altitudes is unpredictable; bad weather and freezing temperatures can make climbing more adventurous. A dry and stable climate is important for a safe climb. The temperature at Mera Peak is between 15 degrees Celcius to 23 degrees Celcius in spring and drops to 10 degrees Celcius to 18 degrees Celcius in autumn. The temperature at Island Peak is similar since both peaks are close to each other in the Mahalangur range.
The best time to climb Mera Peak and Island Peak
Spring (March to May) and Fall (September to November) are the best times to plan trips to Island Peak and Mera Peak. These seasons offer the best conditions for mountaineering in Nepal. Spring and autumn are also the best times for trekking. During Spring and Fall, you get clear skies, stable weather, warm temperatures, bright sunlight, low chances of rain or snow, and beautiful scenery. You won’t find these conditions in Winter and Monsoon.
Monsoons have lots of rain, and winter is cold and snowy. Some climbers attempt it in winter, but the extreme cold can be tough, especially for beginners. It’s not technically challenging, but you must handle the winter cold. Winter and monsoon are unpredictable and unstable. So, autumn and spring are the best times to climb because of their good conditions.
Accommodation and Services
For Mera Peak and Island Peak, you’ll stay in tea houses or lodges in villages along the trekking routes. These places offer basic facilities like beds and shared bathrooms. At higher altitudes and base camps, you’ll camp in tents provided by trekking agencies, which also have cooking and dining tents.
Guides and porters will help you on your trek, with guides showing how porters carry your gear. Trekking agencies arrange necessary permits, provide meals, and offer rental gear like crampons and ice axes. They also handle emergency plans and transportation, including flights to the starting points of the trek.
Conclusion
Mera Peak and Island Peak climbing are very popular and highly successful. Which one is best for you? It depends on what you want from your expedition. You can do Mera Peak climbing if you are a beginner looking for mountaineering experience before tackling more technical climbs. But if you have some high-altitude trekking and mountaineering experience and want to gain more technical skills, or if you’re preparing for higher altitude climbs (7,000 to 8,000 meters), you can do Island Peak Climbing. Both mountain expeditions are amazing and perfect for mountaineering enthusiasts looking to expand their Himalayan experiences.
FAQs
Is Island Peak easy to climb?
Climbing Island Peak is not easy, but you can make it easier by spending more days on the trek and the mountain. You need to get used to the lower oxygen levels as you go up. Most people trying to climb Island Peak don’t reach the summit.
Which is harder, Mera Peak or Island Peak?
Island Peak is generally considered harder than Mera Peak. While both peaks are challenging, Island Peak involves more technical climbing, including sections with fixed ropes and a steep headwall near the summit. On the other hand, Mera Peak is a bit harder but has a more straightforward climb with less technical difficulty.
Is Mera Peak worth it?
Yes, Mera Peak is worth it. From its summit, Mera Peak offers stunning views of Everest, Lhotse, and Makalu. It provides a great introduction to high-altitude climbing without being overly technical.
Can you see Everest from Island Peak?
Yes, you can see Mount Everest from Island Peak. The Island Peak summit offers spectacular views of Everest and other major peaks like Lhotse, Makalu, and Cho Oyu.
Can you climb the Island Peak in winter?
Climbing Island Peak in winter is possible but challenging. Winter can make climbing difficult due to colder temperatures, higher winds, and increased snow and ice on the route.
